Five Stars for #NationalClassicMovieDay

I am here today to join Rick from Classic Movie and TV Cafe in celebration of National Classic Movie Day on May 16. This year Rick is hosting the Five Stars Blogathon, the third installment of the event in hopes of encouraging people to #PayClassicsForward in any way they can. Check out this terrific video he put together to commemorate the special day.

The task at hand is to name five favorite movie stars. I’m sure you can imagine how difficult a task this is for anyone who has loved stars and movies for his/her entire life. Now, before I name names I think it’s important to note that I take these challenges seriously and they never fail to reveal something about me – even to me. For instance, I always go back to my childhood and think of connections I made to movies and the people in them. Those connections are alive in me today and shaped my movie-watching life irrevocably. I remember clearly the first time I saw certain movies or certain people, how I was fascinated by them and the fact that they didn’t look or sound like anyone else I saw or heard in life. Despite having a loving home and great friends, I loved to escape into the movies and still do. So there are many movie stars I feel a connection to for various reasons, but the five I chose to spotlight here are special to me. I’ll try to explain why for each, but first let me explain how I came to choose them.

Last year Rick asked participating blogs to put together a list of the five movies they’d take to a deserted island. That caused a traffic jam in my head for many days, but I was able to pull it together just in time. This year a similar conundrum surfaced right off the bat, but I narrowed my list considerably thanks to Rick’s including the following sentence in his blogathon introduction, “we will shine the spotlight on those actors and actresses that made the Golden Days of Hollywood glitter brightly.” Why did that clear things up for me? Well, because in my fevered head there is an actual cabinet wherein the memories of golden age stars reside in specific, categorized folders. And I came to that realization without therapy, mind you.

The folders are arranged by major category like actor and director with sub-categories in each. As I contemplated the five stars from the actors folder I realized that there is a sub folder for movie stars in which not all actors are placed. In other words, all movie stars are actors, but not all actors are movie stars. Now all I had to do was look in the movie star sub-folder and spotlight the names of those placed there, which are the ones that glittered brightest. Does any of this make sense? Anyway, these movie stars were not necessarily the most talented although they certainly could be. What they had that the actors didn’t necessarily possess were names and images that unto themselves evoke Hollywood – to me. And they are – a supremely talented girl next door, the everyman working-class guy that warms your heart, the icon who could do farce, the ultimate movie star and the pin-up queen.

My stars…

A supremely talented girl next door:

The girl next door who in song after song, movie after movie, year after year wowed me with her talent. At the height of Judy Garland’s amazing career you can find an endless array of genius performances each more affecting than the last – regardless of the movie. Most people recognize the extraordinary gift of her voice, which came from heaven knows where, but the voice was only part of it. It was her interpretation of the songs that make them pockets of brilliance as part of her characterization. Judy was a wonderful actress, which she doesn’t get much credit for. I am lucky to have recognized this talent at an early age and now know that Judy Garland was the greatest entertainer of the 20th Century. On stage and in the movies. I still imagine – on occasion – she lives next door to me.


The everyman working-class guy that warms your heart:

This choice is my meat and potatoes star. In my mind James Stewart is a working actor to be admired for the numerous characters many of us want to spend time with. People like George Bailey, Jefferson Smith, Mr. Hobbs, Macauley Connor, Elwood P. Dowd, Paul Biegler and even L. B. Jeffries. I’ve never associated James Stewart with the glitz and glamour of Hollywood, but for dependability and honesty I’d turn to no one else. This choice for the work ethic my father instilled in me, for the belief that regular folks can achieve greatness and that quirkiness is a trait to be admired. All of that I got from watching Jimmy Stewart in movies.


The icon who do farce:

I’ve blogged about Cary Grant so much that it feels obsessive to include him on this list , but how could I not?

Cary Grant possessed all of the qualities needed to cause a severe elevation in heat in any red-blooded human. The fact that he was so varied a performer, so gifted in various aspects and genres of entertainment is icing. Mr. Grant could do it all and he could do it all believably and with style. He parodied himself and became an icon doing it. There simply is no Hollywood for me without him. This choice is for all the possibilities in just one man.


The ultimate movie star:

What you get when you watch Joan Crawford is glamour and grit. I think Joan’s reputation of being “the ultimate movie star” comes from her absolute drive to reach the top at any cost. That’s admirable in a world where people are all too often cast aside to be replaced by the latest, prettiest thing. The recent series, Feud: Bette and Joan highlighted Joan’s later years in Hollywood as she struggled to remain a working actress well past when most women disappeared from the public eye. Although I enjoyed the series it bothered me that people who might not know Joan Crawford’s entire career would think only of a troubled ex-star when her name is mentioned when in truth Joan Crawford means movie star. From engenue to Queen of Hollywood to fashion influencer to serious actress – all with the grace and fortitude of a true survivor – that’s Joan Crawford, the one who exemplifies why I adore those letters on a hill in Hollywood.


The pin-up queen:

When I was a kid Judy, Cary, Jimmy and Joan were just regular people who I saw in movies. What they portrayed, I mean. They were people I connected with in stories I understood and sometimes wanted to be a part of. But, Betty Grable…well, she was something else altogether. I mean, only the biggest star in the world could wear dresses and sport hairstyles that looked like cake!

I was later to learn that (by all accounts) Betty Grable was as down to Earth as movie stars could be. She was generous and never took the movie thing quite so seriously. A lot of that comes across in her movies, which are pieces of fluffy delight. Grable movies don’t teach lessons overtly, yet I learned valuable things from this pin-up queen who you just can’t help but admire. Of those the most important thing I took away is a belief in songs with invisible orchestras. That’s the musical version of suspension of disbelief, which is critical to the enjoyment of movies and how they evoke beloved memories. It’s a truly wonderful gift Grable gave me and I love her for it – not to mention the fact that the mere mention of her name evokes my favorite era in media history.

Be sure to visit the Classic Film and TV Cafe to read the favorite Five Stars of a fantastic group of bloggers. Then go forth and #PayClassicsForward for #NationalClassicMovieDay.

25 thoughts

  1. Aurora, I absolutely love your introduction and the manner in which you came up with your five stars. James Stewart would certainly be on my list for all the reasons you mentioned. I enjoy all his films, but those from the 1950s–especially the ones directed by Hitchcock and Mann–show what a truly a brilliant actor he was. A terrific list!

  2. This is such a challenge to pick just five! Depending what qualifier you put to choosing it could be a different list each time. Great choices and I love all five of these stars. Judy is I think perhaps the most relatable of all movie stars because the way most people find their way to her as it was for me is though The Wizard of Oz where she is every girl and audience surrogate Dorothy. Despite her turbulent life she always retained at least a remnant of that quality even to her last film I Could Go On Singing as a glamorous, troubled star…and of course her amazing talent.

    Cary, Jimmy and Joan all so different and so singular who offered years of pleasure and I LOVE Betty Grable. Glad you mentioned her elaborate look. Her clothes were eye popping but it was those hairdos, so incredibly involved that we were supposed to believe she simply whipped into shape in minutes, that I delighted in seeing. Her films are breezy affairs that chase the blues away.

  3. Your reasoning as you narrowed down your list makes perfect sense. You could not do it any other way. I believe your five stars would thank you.

    The first Betty Grable movie I showed Janet was My Blue Heaven. Halfway through the movie the daughter announced that she liked Betty Grable. Betty seemed like someone you could have as a friend.

    1. Thank you so much. I’m always thrilled to be asked to participate in the Marathon Link Party, but I can’t seem to figure out how to add my posts. Much appreciated nonetheless. 🙂

      1. Click on the link I left. Scroll down past the rules section and click on the “add your link” button. It will take you to a new screen. Enter your post link in the first box and if you just click in the second box it will pull in the title of your post and the pictures on that post. Add your email address. Scroll past all of the images and click done. That’s it. It is easier than it seems.

  4. Best line I’ve read today, “only the biggest star in the world could wear dresses and sport hairstyles that looked like cake!” Love your list! I love Philadelphia Story since it features both Grant and Stewart together. The played off each other so well that I wish they had been paired together more often. They could have had an onscreen bromance like Spencer Tracy and Clark Gable did.

  5. A terrific intro and five magnificent selections. My only quibble, and you can smack me with a wet noddle if you like for this, is I would narrow Crawford down to the ultimate female movie star and add you guy Mr. Grant as the male equivalent: Charisma, style, wit, talent, versatility, he had it all. 🙂

    1. You get no noodle for that one, John. There is no one who stands up to Mr. Grant in any way, shape or form. But as far as the title goes and the hunger to obtain it I don’t think anyone rivals Joanie.

  6. Just listened to the You Must Remember This podcast on Crawford, so it was fun to see her appreciated here right afterward. I am so impressed with her toughness. Great choices. And that cake line is hilarious.

  7. Yours is the first blog where I have seen Jimmy Stewart and Joan Crawford listed, and I am amazed that other film fans have not selected these two giants. “Judy Garland was the greatest entertainer of the 20th century”. How true!

  8. I am 100% with you on Judy. I do believe she was the most over-all talented person ever in film. There was nothing that woman could not do. As for Cary…. well, you know we are in complete agreement on that! Anf JOan – yes – lots of love for Joan.

  9. Great picks Aurora. I’m glad you picked Joan Crawford, and Betty Grable too. Joan was getting some bad press there on HBO but she WAS Hollywood, no matter what Betty said. And that other symbol of Hollywood Judy Garland. Super list.

Leave a Reply to vp19 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s